The “Little” Penn Theater

Perhaps the only photo of the theater shows author Paul (age 12) with his uncle Ben Siegal in 1944. Courtesy of Carol Horowitz.

by Paul Roth

The principal business of my branch in the Roth Family was the Penn, a moving picture theater owned and operated by my grandfather, Israel (Joe) Roth.

This was not the “big” Penn Theater, the major stage and screen venue on the northwest corner of Sixth Street and Penn Avenue in Downtown Pittsburgh (now Heinz Hall). This was the “little” Penn Theater in the city’s Lawrenceville neighborhood, across from the doughboy statue at 3414 Penn Avenue—just east of Butler Street.

It was a modest venue: a single-floor auditorium, separated from the lobby by a curtain. A lone candy machine in the lobby offered such treats as Raisinets, Milk Duds, and Good & Plenty licorice. Outside, a minimal marquee framed the box office. We are lucky to have a 1944 snapshot of the Penn, sent to me by my cousin Carol Horowitz, for which I’m very grateful. My uncle Ben Siegal and I, age 12, are pictured outside the entrance. A funny quirk was that the building was a block and a half from a bridge that carried a Baltimore and Ohio rail line across Penn Avenue. It occasionally imparted to the theater some pronounced jarring and rattling.

An undated clipping, circa 1950, says H.J. Heinz built the Penn in 1915 for operation by his friend, a Mr. Artsburger; my grandfather took over in 1924. The article, titled “Israel Roth, Pittsburgh Exhibitor 25 Years, Leases Penn; Retires,” announced Grandpa’s retirement and transfer of the theater to the Shea Theatre Company that operated the Fulton downtown. The theater presented second- (or sometimes third-) run films accompanied by an assortment of serials, newsreels, and weekly contests such as “bank night.”

Over my youth, the personnel of the Penn remained constant: Walter, the manager; Peggy, the ticket seller; and Mister Michelosky, the projectionist. Besides that staff, Grandpa’s son—my uncle Jerry Roth—had a big role in promoting, developing, and modernizing the theater. Before and after World War II (in which he served as a decorated transportation officer), he introduced many technological innovations and improvements to its operation.

On innumerable visits to my grandparents and some extended stays, I “inhabited” the theater and got to know it intimately, including trips upstairs to the projection room with its acrid odor of burning projection lamps. I use the term “inhabited” because many of my visits accompanied Grandpa Joe and lasted for hours. In essence, Gene Autry, Roy Rogers, Dick Tracy, the Green Hornet, Tarzan, and other screen characters became my babysitters.

I also recall the route from home to the theater that my grandfather always took in his 1939 Pontiac, Negley Ave. to Friendship St. to Liberty Ave. to Penn Ave.

3 & 4) The former Penn Theater, across from Lawrenceville’s doughboy statue, is identifiable by its decorative tilework. It is now home to The Pittsburgh Juice Company. Images by Paul Roth, 2021.
3 & 4) The former Penn Theater, across from Lawrenceville’s doughboy statue, is identifiable by its decorative tilework. It is now home to The Pittsburgh Juice Company. Images by Paul Roth, 2021.

Another advantage of associating with Grandpa was occasional trips to the neighborhood called “Film Row,” where the major movie studios had sales offices and screening facilities. There, I got to see new films and acquire many brochures and trade magazines, such as BOXOFFICE. What remains of this enclave is the marquee of the restored Paramount Film Exchange building, which still displays the studio’s stunning logo above the entrance facing the Boulevard of The Allies.

One of my souvenirs of the theater was Grandpa’s pocket schedule notebook for 1942, which, in his precise script, listed the entire year’s presentations, including feature and short films and audience-participation events. There was also a complete listing of the presentations at the theater’s principal competitors, the Model (Bloomfield) and the Arsenal (Lawrenceville). Several years ago, I donated this precious relic to the History Center.

Pages from Israel Roth’s diary include handwritten abbreviations that apparently represent the studio which released each feature film: Met – Metro Goldwyn Mayer, VIT – Vitaphone, Par – Paramount, Rep – Republic, UA – United Artists. The right page notation represents the competing theaters: A – Arsenal (Lawrenceville), M – Model (Bloomfield). Detre Library & Archives.

The last time I was in the neighborhood, I was pleased to see the building that housed the theater still stands, partly restored, now home to The Pittsburgh Juice Company.

Paul Roth is a regular contributor to Western Pennsylvania History, the History Center’s quarterly magazine.

3 thoughts on “The “Little” Penn Theater

  1. As a member of the Roth family. I am one of Joe Roth’s grandchildren, I remember the stories of the theater too. The one I love the most is my Mother’s, Ethel Roth Siegal. When the theater played the “Phantom of the Opera, she had to hide under her very large brimmed hat and slink down in her seat because she was so terrified.

  2. Thanks Paul for the interesting history on the little theater. It is interesting how the movie making has changed especially now within 10 years or so. there is so much streaming, I wonder what will be the future of the brick and mortar movie theaters. Best regards, keep safe, Martin

  3. There is another view of the Penn Theater in the Spring 2018 issue of Western Pennsylvania History on page 53. It’s a photo we got for Jim Wudarczyk’s and my article about Lawrenceville’s Doughboy Statue. I scanned other views from Phyllis Renda’s collection of photos her relations took, but the one in the article has the sharpest detail. Fun Fact: the downtown Penn Theater was referred to in the newspapers as “Loew’s Penn” as the “Little Penn” had the name before the downtown Penn was opened in 1927. If you don’t have a copy of the Spring 2018 issue, you can find a PDF of it here…

Leave a Reply

« « Wait For It: Hamilton in Pittsburgh | Rev. LeRoy Patrick: Advocate for Equality » »